CandyMail vs Posted Sweets: Which Is Better for Sweets?
Last Updated: November 8, 2026
Quick Summary
CandyMail vs Posted Sweets is a choice between convenience and variety: CandyMail suits letterbox subscriptions and gift presentation, while Posted Sweets offers a wider retro and American range with better customisation. Compare cost per 100g plus delivery before ordering, since pack weights vary and headline prices mislead.
CandyMail's mixes are largely fixed bundles, while Posted Sweets lets you build more of your own selection.
CandyMail reviews praise subscription convenience and delivery speed but criticise portion sizes relative to price.
Compare cost per 100g on equivalent products, then add delivery charges to the basket total.
Check the stated weight in grams, not the number of items or box size, before deciding value.
Confirm the tracking option at checkout rather than assuming it is included for gifts.
Gift or bulk buy: which sweet shop fits?
Sweet junkies offers traditional pick and mix, retro sweets, in-house freeze-dried sweets and American snacks.
Table of Contents
CandyMail vs Posted Sweets: How the Two Shops Compare
Choosing between CandyMail vs Posted Sweets comes down to what you want from an online sweet shop: speed, range, or the personal touch of a smaller retailer. This guide from Sweet junkies breaks down both shops side by side, from pick and mix selection to delivery and pricing, so you can order with confidence.
We run a traditional pick and mix shop ourselves, so we know how much the small details matter when sweets travel through the post. Below, we'll show you exactly where each shop stands out, where it falls short, and which type of shopper each one suits best.
Both CandyMail and Posted Sweets are established online sweet retailers with loyal followings. CandyMail leans heavily on subscription-style letterbox sweets and gifting, while Posted Sweets built its reputation on a wide retro and American candy range. Neither is a bad choice, but they serve different shoppers.
Pick and Mix Sweets Online: Range and Customisation

Customisation is where both shops differ most. CandyMail's mixes are largely fixed bundles, while Posted Sweets lets you build more of your own selection. That matters if you are buying for a picky child's birthday or a themed event.
Sweet Hampers and Gift Boxes: Who Does Gifting Better?
For a baby shower, gender reveal, or a gift that needs to arrive looking the part, CandyMail's packaging has the edge. For a big shared box of retro sweets at a family gathering, Posted Sweets is the more practical spend.
CandyMail Reviews: What Customers Actually Say
CandyMail reviews tend to praise the convenience of the subscription model and the speed of delivery. Shoppers who want a regular treat through the door rate it highly.
The common criticism in CandyMail reviews is value for money. Some customers feel the portion sizes are small relative to the price, and a few mention that the fixed mixes limit choice.
Customer service feedback is generally positive, with most complaints centred on expectations rather than failures. If you go in knowing you are paying for convenience and presentation, you will not be disappointed.
Posted Sweets Reviews: What Customers Actually Say
For anyone who needs a gift to arrive on a specific date, build in extra time.
Delivery, Packaging and Customer Service Compared
Feature | CandyMail | Posted Sweets |
Delivery style | Letterbox-friendly pouches | Parcel delivery |
Packaging focus | Gift presentation | Practical bulk packing |
Range depth | Curated | Extensive |
Customisation | Limited | Good |
Best for | Gifts and subscriptions | Variety and retro seekers |
Dispatch times can vary with order volume, and busy periods can add days. Build in extra time if you need a gift to arrive on a specific date.
Tracking is worth checking before you order. If you are sending a gift and need to know when it lands, confirm the tracking option at checkout rather than assuming it is included.
For guidance on allergens in confectionery, the Food Standards Agency allergen guidance is the reliable starting point. If a parcel arrives damaged, photograph it before opening and contact the shop promptly; most retailers will replace or refund once they can see the problem.
Pricing and Value: Which Offers Better Worth?
Headline prices are misleading in online sweets because pack weights vary so much. The only fair way to compare CandyMail and Posted Sweets is to look at cost per 100g on equivalent products, then add delivery. Neither shop publishes a standard price list that makes this easy, so you will need to check the pack weight on each product page before you commit.
Delivery charges change the maths. Always compare the basket total including postage, not the product price alone.
Watch out: a cheaper box often contains noticeably less. Check the stated weight in grams, not the number of items or the size of the box, before you decide which shop is better value for your order.
You pay for range, novelty, and delivery. The question is which of those you value most, and whether the pack weight and delivery charge still make sense once you have done the sums.
Choosing Your Sweet Shop: What to Compare Before You Order
Before you commit, run through this quick checklist:
Does the shop stock the specific sweets you want, or only generic mixes?
Is the pack weight stated clearly, so you can compare value fairly?
Are allergens and dietary information easy to find?
Does delivery suit your timing, especially for gifts?
Is the packaging right for the occasion?
At Sweet junkies, we take a different approach again. We run a large traditional pick and mix shop with retro and modern sweets, and we make our own freeze-dried sweets. We also stock American drinks and international crisps. When you are ready to compare the options and place an order, you can browse the Sweet junkies range.
The right shop depends on whether you are buying a gift or stocking up for a crowd. Sweet junkies makes that choice easier with a large traditional pick and mix, retro and modern sweets, freeze-dried sweets made in-house, and American drinks and international crisps all in one place. Get started with Sweet junkies and build a sweet box that suits the occasion.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between CandyMail and Posted Sweets?
CandyMail and Posted Sweets both sell pick and mix sweets online, but they differ in range and focus. CandyMail leans towards letterbox-friendly sweet boxes and customised treats, while Posted Sweets stocks a broad selection of retro sweets, American candy and international snacks. Before ordering, compare their pick and mix sweets online ranges, delivery times and packaging to see which suits your needs.
Which is better for pick and mix sweets, CandyMail or Posted Sweets?
Pricing and availability depend on quantity, dates and delivery. For current prices or a quote, see the Sweet junkies website.
Does Posted Sweets sell retro sweets and gift hampers?
Yes, Posted Sweets stocks traditional and retro sweets alongside American candy and international snacks, and it offers sweet hampers and gift boxes for occasions such as birthdays and celebrations. The range changes with availability, so check the website for current stock and hamper options before ordering.
What should I compare before ordering sweets online?
When choosing a sweet shop, check the product range and availability, delivery timing and packaging, and whether allergens are clearly listed. For current prices or a quote, see the Sweet junkies website.







Comments